Goaltending or Block?

[SubGod22]

I disagree here. If the guy is goaltending then the other team gets two points automatically. Thats pretty generous. The flip side should be if the guy was NOT goaltending and made a great stop, then he gets the ball back.

Then what about a double violation on a FT? IF this were to be a rule it would go to alternating possession as neither team had possession and you can't guarantee who would have gotten possession.

I'm intrigued by the thought of this being a rule, but can pretty much guarantee that alternating possession is how possession would be decided.

[Kung Wu]

Then what about a double violation on a FT? IF this were to be a rule it would go to alternating possession as neither team had possession and you can't guarantee who would have gotten possession.

I'm intrigued by the thought of this being a rule, but can pretty much guarantee that alternating possession is how possession would be decided.

Yeah I know it won't happen like I want it to, but I am not a fan of alternating possessions. This rule doesn't need to be confused with any others. The blocker is the last one to touch the ball and thats enough to award him with the ball if the call was incorrect. Again it wouldn't happen that way, but it's the best way in my opinion. Especially if you are going to automatically award points if the call was correct (which I also am not a fan of).

[WuDrWu]

A)It wasn't goaltending.
B)The 2 other officials (as I speculated) were furious with Randall for making the call.
C)Not 1 out of 100 D1 Officials make that call there.
D)Randall's work load will get lighter in the Valley.

[ShockerGorilla]

D)Randall's work load will get lighter in the Valley.

I'll believe it when I see it. How many times have we been screwed before & nothing happens? This feels like the 1.9 seconds against Creighton.

[1979Shocker]

A)B)The 2 other officials (as I speculated) were furious with Randall for making the call.

Is there a link? What all was said?

[WuDrWu]

Sorry, no link.

[AZ Shocker]

It's cool the kid that hit the winning shot is a freshmen. That kid must be a Top-20 national player and the Valley's best incoming recruit EVER!!! Clearly as a Top Blue-chipper player playing for the Valley's LAST PLACE team....a FRESHMEN should absolutely get the Micheal Jordan treatment by the refs in order to travel, charge and get a home-cooked goaltend call to beat the #22 team in the country. It's science. Way to go Valley refs!!! Way to go!!!!!!!!

[pinstripers]

If the ref thought it was a goaltend, I think you call it a goaltend. The rulebook shouldn't change.