The most in depth college baseball coverage is done by these guys. They've done a top 100 program rating starting in 2015, 2017, 2019 and they are doing one now.
The criteria from their website is:
https://d1baseball.com/analysis/2022...ograms-91-100/
"For the purpose of this exercise, we don’t care what happened in the 1970s or 80s, or even the 90s or 2000s — that’s ancient history to a potential recruit in 2021. Tradition is nice, but it’s more important to establish a tradition of consistent winning in the last decade, and especially in the last five years. Our ultimate goal here is to identify the programs in the best shape right now, with an eye toward the next five to 10 years.
So we began by awarding each program points for making regionals, winning regionals, reaching the College World Series, and winning the national championship in the last five (completed) seasons, and a fewer amount of points for success between six and 10 years ago. That gave us a starting point; then national writers Aaron Fitt, Kendall Rogers and Mike Rooney made adjustments based on evaluations of coaching staff quality and stability, facilities, scholarship/financial aid situation, conference dynamics, momentum, and recruiting and player development proficiency. As the chairman of the Division I Baseball Committee likes to say every year, it’s more of an art than a science, but we tried to take many factors into consideration and debated our rankings internally at length."
In 2015, WSU was #73, #3 in the MVC, #2 in Kansas. They expected a big jump based on current conditions (Butler etc)
2017 WSU was #100. Things didn't go as planned, moving to the AAC, a key time for this once storied program.
2019 WSU was not in the top 100.
2022 WSU is of course not in the top 100. Programs of note that are:
#100 is SE Missouri State and #99 is Nevada. Proof positive of their criteria about winning against competition as I doubt many informed folks at all would place either of those 2 programs on par with WSU utilizing any other measuring stick.
#97 Tulane
#91 UCF
#88 Creighton
#80 Rice
#75 ORU
#74 Charlotte
#71 Long Beach State
#63 USF
#60 Indiana State
#59 Missouri State
#52 FAU
#51 Houston
#43 Nebraska
#29 Uconn
#27 DBU
#23 Oklahoma
#22 East Carolina
#20 Auburn
#19 Oklahoma State
#18 TCU
#17 Tennessee
#16 NC State
#15 Virginia
#14 North Carolina
#13 Florida State
#12 Texas
#11 Texas A&M
#10 Stanford
#9 Texas Tech
#8 Ole Miss
#7 LSU
#6 Louisville
#5 Oregon State
#4 Florida
#3 Mississippi State
#2 Arkansas
#1 Vanderbilt
If you're counting, 9 SEC teams in the top 20, if you weren't sure where the football money is going these days.
*Updated*
Separate issue; Clearly the program isn't where anyone wants or more importantly expects it to be. Not fans, admins, coaches or players. One thing that needs to be addressed is the stadium. Parts are in disrepair. Seats broken. Those things need to be fixed, replaced, upgraded....whatever....and before we spend $50 million on women's soccer.
6 of the 10 new conference programs are top 100 (according to this list). WSU, Memphis, UTSA and UAB are not. (UNT doesn't sponsor baseball nor does Temple nor SMU).
The criteria from their website is:
https://d1baseball.com/analysis/2022...ograms-91-100/
"For the purpose of this exercise, we don’t care what happened in the 1970s or 80s, or even the 90s or 2000s — that’s ancient history to a potential recruit in 2021. Tradition is nice, but it’s more important to establish a tradition of consistent winning in the last decade, and especially in the last five years. Our ultimate goal here is to identify the programs in the best shape right now, with an eye toward the next five to 10 years.
So we began by awarding each program points for making regionals, winning regionals, reaching the College World Series, and winning the national championship in the last five (completed) seasons, and a fewer amount of points for success between six and 10 years ago. That gave us a starting point; then national writers Aaron Fitt, Kendall Rogers and Mike Rooney made adjustments based on evaluations of coaching staff quality and stability, facilities, scholarship/financial aid situation, conference dynamics, momentum, and recruiting and player development proficiency. As the chairman of the Division I Baseball Committee likes to say every year, it’s more of an art than a science, but we tried to take many factors into consideration and debated our rankings internally at length."
In 2015, WSU was #73, #3 in the MVC, #2 in Kansas. They expected a big jump based on current conditions (Butler etc)
2017 WSU was #100. Things didn't go as planned, moving to the AAC, a key time for this once storied program.
2019 WSU was not in the top 100.
2022 WSU is of course not in the top 100. Programs of note that are:
#100 is SE Missouri State and #99 is Nevada. Proof positive of their criteria about winning against competition as I doubt many informed folks at all would place either of those 2 programs on par with WSU utilizing any other measuring stick.
#97 Tulane
#91 UCF
#88 Creighton
#80 Rice
#75 ORU
#74 Charlotte
#71 Long Beach State
#63 USF
#60 Indiana State
#59 Missouri State
#52 FAU
#51 Houston
#43 Nebraska
#29 Uconn
#27 DBU
#23 Oklahoma
#22 East Carolina
#20 Auburn
#19 Oklahoma State
#18 TCU
#17 Tennessee
#16 NC State
#15 Virginia
#14 North Carolina
#13 Florida State
#12 Texas
#11 Texas A&M
#10 Stanford
#9 Texas Tech
#8 Ole Miss
#7 LSU
#6 Louisville
#5 Oregon State
#4 Florida
#3 Mississippi State
#2 Arkansas
#1 Vanderbilt
If you're counting, 9 SEC teams in the top 20, if you weren't sure where the football money is going these days.
*Updated*
Separate issue; Clearly the program isn't where anyone wants or more importantly expects it to be. Not fans, admins, coaches or players. One thing that needs to be addressed is the stadium. Parts are in disrepair. Seats broken. Those things need to be fixed, replaced, upgraded....whatever....and before we spend $50 million on women's soccer.
6 of the 10 new conference programs are top 100 (according to this list). WSU, Memphis, UTSA and UAB are not. (UNT doesn't sponsor baseball nor does Temple nor SMU).
Comment